Week 3:
I gave the Pre VTS assessment to my Foundations of Art class. All of my students were present
during this class. It is a mix grade level group; consisting mostly of freshman and sophomores
with one Senior and a few juniors. They are all in this basic class with very little prior knowledge of
art at all. After reviewing the results of the assessment, a lot of the students came up with a common
story line. Some students revealed more evidence then some of the others. A lot of the students
created a story with predictions on what they were viewing. This class has about half of the student
population that requires accommodations due to a Learning Profile, aka IEP. I was surprised on
how well they did with telling me what they saw in writing. But I was also very disappointed in
some students writing skills.
I believe that the students fall within Housen’s description of Stage one:
Accountive viewers are storytellers. Using their senses, memories, and personal associations, they
make concrete observations about a work of art that are woven into a narrative. Here, judgments
are based on what is known and what is liked. Emotions color viewers' comments, as they seem to
enter the work of art and become part of its unfolding narrative.
They all had a narrative and told me a story about the painting. They all had some predictions. I am
looking forward to when the students can write and vividly describe what they see. One of my
schools common goals is writing skills. I think lessons like this will help improve writing. I also think
that the students will like these writing lessons because there is no right or wrong answer. They are
simply telling a story about what they are viewing and providing evidence to back up their story.
I am very excited about using this more in my class!
Your reflections on this pre-VTS assessment proves Housen & Yenawine's assertion that stage is not tied to age; that viewers with no art viewing experience will necessarily be at State One, even if they are 85 years old. Your students are using the save storytelling strategies that Ashley's are; their vocabularies and the experiences they draw from are just broader....perhaps.
ReplyDeleteYou mentioned the diversity of the class and that you have many students with special accommodations. I think you will be able to endorse the face that VTS differentiates instruction so effortlessly; that students can enter the discussion from wherever they are cognitively and experientially.
I, too, am excited about this class!